Not sure, but i take it you are having a crack at Alain Rolland? I hate the guy (personal oppinion) i believe he makes incorrect calls and he is biased towards the french (again my opinion). But the IRB must see to good in him because he is a well used ref (he even refed the 2007 world cup final) so nomatter what the opinion is of him we have to understand there is somebody out there who knows alot more rugby than all of us who thinks hes good. P.s. Rolland was ref when England beat France last year, just some added information hope this helps :p